Fandom Snowflake 2025 Challenge #6

[scrubjayspeaks]

Challenge #6

Share your favourite piece of original canon. Post your answer to today’s challenge in your own space and leave a comment in this post saying you did it. Include a link to your post if you feel comfortable doing so.

I've been revisiting The Lord of the Rings books, and I recently finished Two Towers. This was previously the section I found least interesting, but this read-through hit different.

Éomer and Faramir both have speeches about what they will decide to do when they capture, more or less, members of the fellowship. Éomer has to decide if he will let Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli go on their way--with loaned horses, even--when he has orders to detain and bring back to King Théoden anyone he hasn't summarily killed. Faramir is under similar orders from Gondor when he meets Frodo, Sam, and Gollum.

They monologue their way through the moral dilemma, weighing options and motivations. Both of them invoke ideas of manhood and honor in a way that really grabbed hold of me. They ultimately both decide that trust, and compassion, and solidarity are more important than blind adherence to rules and authority. It's not that they're disloyal to their leaders. But they decide that their honor will not let them betray vulnerable strangers.

I've been paying particular attention to what being a good man means in the series. It's full of men who recite poetry, and speak tenderly of friends, and feel deeply the sufferings of their times. They're brave and steadfast, prepared to endure terrible things. They don't glory in the terrible things, though, or even in their ability to bear up under them. It is strength without hardness. It is strength that longs for, and works toward, the days when it will not be needed.

There's a lot of advice floating around about how to pass as a man. And a lot of it amounts to "wear drab colors, be less expressive, be harder and more withdrawn." Which all seem like a wretched way of defining manhood. They might be necessary to pass, since those do seem to be the expectations of men in our current overculture. But I keep looking for models of manhood that don't settle for this flattening of a person.